Can you pass the geek test?

Fandom

When I was in Japantown, I spent a lot of time checking out the mall’s enormous selection of Gundam models. I didn’t have any room in my stuffed carry-on suitcase, but that didn’t keep me from window shopping. Lately I’ve been lusting after unusual models, like the Acguy and Z’gok.

At the store with the biggest selection, a group of four guys were standing in front of the wall of Gundams, blocking my view. They didn’t seem to notice me, so I said “excuse me,” in order to get through. That seemed to surprise the tallest of the guys.

“Wait,” he said. “You build Gundams?”

I nodded. As I’ve written before, I built my first Gundam a few years ago and have dabbled in tougher models since. I even wrote a Gundam modeling tutorial for beginners.

“Really. What’s the last model you built?” he asked. It may have just been in my head, but I felt like he didn’t believe me.

Perhaps it was the pressure, but I couldn’t remember the full name of the last model I’d built, an MS-06S Char’s Zaku Real Grade.

“A… Zaku,” I said.

That seemed to make him upset.

“There are a lot of Zaku models,” he pointed out.

“It was the new one, the real grade,” I said. (Real grade is one of the building difficulty levels defined in my tutorial.)

“Those aren’t even hard to build,” he replied.

I was feeling increasingly flustered, so I called over to Steven, who was in another part of the store, and we left together.

I had just been an unwitting recipient of the “geek test,” a pop quiz some fans give to verify the geek cred of people they don’t think belong in their fandom. I was frustrated with myself for playing along.

As I explained on ANNCast, this isn’t the first time this has happened to me. As a woman, I know I’m not alone. It’s the reason I wrote about why I can’t be a hot girl and a nerd at the same time. Even if I feel like I’m blending in at a Magic: The Gathering event, somebody will ask me where my boyfriend is and break the spell. Even though I was there with my fiance, nobody asked him where his girlfriend was.

I hate to admit it, but the whole experience left me wondering, perhaps I should be trying to build more difficult Gundam models. That guy is going to assume that women aren’t good at model building, just because the woman he did meet was an amateur. Like it or not, whenever I choose to indulge in male dominated hobbies, I am an ambassador for my gender.

Have you ever been given the “geek test” by a fellow fan? Did you pass?

Photo by Fiends Ain’t Family on Flickr.

Otaku Journalist in Japantown

Uncategorized

 Exactly one week before today, I was standing in San Francisco’s Japantown, a six block weeaboo wonderland. It’s taken me this long to write about it because nothing I can say will ever live up to how I felt when I was there. There’s no way to do it justice, so I’m just going to give you the facts.

I was in San Francisco for business, more specifically, to attend the LiveJournal community leader summit. I Even though it meant missing out on Katsucon, I decided to extend my trip for one extra day so I could finally explore Japantown, a part of the city I’d been dying to visit since I saw it on America’s Greatest Otaku. As it turned out, I’d picked the perfect date to do it; Saturday also marked the first day of a local geek convention, Animation on Display.

In the morning, I met up at the convention hotel, Hotel Kabuki, with my host, Steven Savage. As I’ve written before, Steven is a geek career expert and the author of Fan to Pro, a book that changed the course of my career. We’ve been in touch online for more than a year, but this was our first time meeting in person. Here’s us standing in the courtyard pretending like we know each other.

Steven was busy; he presented three different panels that day. (I attended the two on geek careers, and will be recapping at least one.) But he still made sure that I experienced all the essentials of a trip to Japantown, namely, shopping and eating too much.

Here’s a diptych of photos I took inside the immense mall that connects to Hotel Kabuki and takes up half of Japantown from there. The bridge is usually packed with people, but Steven and I showed up just as the mall was opening up. To the right is a literal wall of figures. You should have seen their Gundam selection!

I’ve never seen shops as anime fan-targeted as those at the mall. For example, several stores were dedicated simply to manga, and there was a shop that sold cosplay off the rack. Animation on Display was a small convention with about 1,000 attendees, but it was almost as if it was attached to a three-block dealer’s room year-round. If we had a place like this on the east coast, I’m sure we’d hold all our conventions there.

There was no shortage of food options, either. Above is an okonomiyaki, a sweet potato pancake with savory chicken and shrimp, that Steven ordered. I had the less photogenic salmon-ikura donburi and beef curry. I couldn’t get over the availability of Japanese snacks either—you could buy onigiri and dango right from a food stand. For somebody who makes her own onigiri at home since she can’t buy it anywhere, it was unbelievable.

Probably the best part was being able to mingle with a completely new group of fans. Now that I’ve been attending east coast conventions for years, I always see familiar faces. At AOD, I was introduced to new people, new panels, and new projects I’d never heard of. I also got to meet some of the bronies interviewed in this Wall Street Journal article.

Anyone who’s tired of the same old stuff on the east coast should definitely check out what they’re doing out west. For example, I loved their idea of holding mixers, super-casual panels for meeting other bronies, for example, or other people with careers in geekdom. (And it goes without saying that west coasters should see what we’re doing over here.)

My visit caused me to realize the Internet hasn’t yet bridged the different forms fandom takes in different parts of the country and, no doubt, the world. It’s worth taking a trip to see the other coast, even if it’s not for a bigger con like Anime Expo or Otakon. (In fact, based on my experience, I’d encourage seeing a smaller con.) My physical visit helped me realize that the fans in my area make up just a small part of the global marketplace of ideas.

In conclusion, I certainly hope that wasn’t my last visit to Japantown. Until then, check out my photo gallery. I took hundreds of photos, but hardly any of them came out because my hands were literally shaking with excitement. It was an experience I won’t soon forget.

The Inside Story: A shout out to my bronies

Uncategorized

The title of this post is, first of all, a quote from Stephen Colbert, back when he acknowledged his brony brethren on his show back in August. Second, it’s a title suggestion from my boss, who encouraged me to blog about my latest high-traffic story. And third, it’s a thank you to everyone who read my story and proved there’s still a (big) audience for fact-driven reporting.

Fandom is a tricky topic. It’s full of detailed minutia, inside jokes and memes, fanart and fanfiction that delves so far away from canon that even the original creators might not understand it. Frankly, it’s a lot for an outsider to handle, and a reporter’s job is to inform even somebody who is hearing about the group for the first time.

As a result, a lot of fandom stories follow simplified themes, dumbing down or even misconstruing what the culture is actually about. It’s usually well intentioned, but still kind of difficult to read for somebody who’s embedded deeply in the fandom.

When I wrote Researchers strive to understand brony culture for the Daily Dot, my goal was to write a story that informed outsiders without dumbing the culture down. Something both my mom and Mister Spectre could read, in which they would each find something of value.

After my editor ran it over, I knew it was outsider-perfect, but I wasn’t sure what bronies would think. Everything in this story is either a quote from one of the researchers or a sourced fact. There’s no flattery or pandering to the fandom. If they did find it, I knew it’d have to be based on its informational merit.

For two days, they didn’t find it. And then I sent it to Sethisto, the webmaster of Equestria Daily. For the uninformed, that’s the brony community’s most highly trafficked news hub. Seth’s verbatim response to my email: “SCIENCE! Totally postin!” It spread from there.

The blog post with my story in it has 140 comments and counting, and I’m going to try to read them all (brony comments are much, MUCH more pleasant than comments in virtually any other community). It’s not just because I’m happy to have a hit. It’s that it’s more proof of my belief that fandom reporting doesn’t have to be opinionated to get clicks. It’s already interesting enough on its own.

Screenshots via Equestria Daily

Otaku Journalist on ANNCast: Hold the hate mail!

Uncategorized

On Wednesday night, I was a guest on ANNCast to talk about sexism in anime and fandom. It’s the most popular podcast I’ve ever been on, and certainly the most structured.

We talked until midnight for me (since I’m on the East Coast, they’re three hours behind), and I’m usually in bed by eleven. I prepared some notes before we started talking, but I don’t think I had enough of a filter. Simply put, as soon as I signed off of Skype, my fiancé said to me, “You’re gonna get hate mail for that.”

He’s probably right. I’m definitely going to get shit for accusing lolicon fans of being childish, for saying that geek culture rewards women who act like sluts, and other equally unfiltered remarks. The former high school debater in me cringes, but these raw musings probably made the podcast more interesting than if I had been my most thoughtful, polished self. At least that’s what I’m telling myself!

Give it a listen here.

How to get a reporter to write about you

Journalism

Lately I’ve been writing a lot of profile pieces. These are stories that focus on one person or a small group. It can sometimes be more exhausting to write a few, thoughtful profile pieces than it is to hammer out lots of quick fact-driven news pieces, but I welcome them. I became a journalist because I wanted to tell people’s stories.

Here’s a few of the criteria I use when I’m deciding who to interview next:

Be an expert

When I was drafting my article about how cosplayers use social networks to get jobs, I knew there would be no higher authority on the subject than my friend and mentor, Steven Savage. Steven literally wrote the book on cosplay careers, making him the perfect source for the topic. It’s unlikely that I could find somebody more knowledgable, no matter where I looked.

Generally, it’s not a good idea for journalists to interview their friends. In my experience, however, I’ve learned to break that rule. Not all the time, but there are instances in which a familiar source is my best bet. Those instances are almost always when that connection is an expert on the particular subject I need to cover.

That’s the difference between a journalist and a press liaison: a source’s relationship with a reporter needs to be symbiotic. I don’t go out of my way to promote friends or acquaintances for no reason, but I always need experts for my stories. That’s why Help A Reporter Out is such a great program. If you want to be in the news, make your expertise known.

Be inspirational

At first, I wasn’t sure if Misa on Wheels was a story. I stumbled on her Facebook page through a link from a Tumblr blog, and was immediately fascinated by her story and her position as a motivational figure in the cosplay community.

However, I’ve gotten almost too good at second guessing my instincts for a fandom story. I’ve got a soft spot for fandom, so I figure just because I find something interesting doesn’t mean it’ll entice a general audience. Doubtful, I showed it to my editor, and he told me to run with it. I wrote the story and it became the most popular item published today.

What makes Misa’s story such a popular profile piece when other people’s wouldn’t be? She’s already had a following of thousands. I already had proof that she could motivate people in her own community, so it was a safe bet that she’d be able to inspire people outside of it, too.

Reporters don’t make news, they share it. I’d like to flatter myself that a profile piece by me would turn a person with zero audience into an overnight sensation, but that simply isn’t true. That’s why it’s helpful to have proof of a subject’s power to inspire.

Be really, really weird

When I do find something that both I and the mainstream media find interesting, I often don’t like it for the same reasons. For example, bronies fascinate me because of their enthusiasm, leading to a prolific fanart and fanfiction output like no fandom before. But I realize other people might look at the group as a whole and see a freak show. That’s what guarantees them a media spotlight.

Generally, everyone likes a good freak show to gawk at. It’s like I wrote about in a previous blog post, How a civil war reenactment is like an anime convention. The TV reporters were looking for the most beautiful and weirdest people to interview. People love to hear about religious fanatics, two faced kittens, even your waifu; anything that has the power to shock and outrage. If you’re weird enough, you can pretty much guarantee an interview.

There’s a downside to being selected as the media’s latest freak, though. It’s press, but it won’t necessarily make you look good. And regardless of the subject at hand, people are going to want to hear all about your sex life. But these profiles almost always turn out to be much bigger hits than profiles on experts or inspirational figures. It depends on whether you think the risk is worth it.


If you’ve got a story that sounds like the sort of thing I’d write for the Daily Dot, send me an email.